Laura Street Trio Demolition Discussions

The Future of the Laura Street Trio: Demolition on the Horizon?

The historic Laura Street Trio, a cornerstone of Jacksonville’s architectural heritage, faces an uncertain future as city officials weigh the possibility of demolition. This trio of buildings, which includes the Florida National Bank, the W.A. Bisbee Building, and the Florida Life Insurance Company Building, has remained vacant for decades, despite numerous restoration attempts.

New Deal or No Deal?

The new deal proposed by the developer is over $85 million in city incentives utilizing taxpayer dollars to restore The Laura Street Trio of buildings, with a total development cost over $188 million.

The primary argument for demolition centers around the significant cost and logistical challenges associated with restoring these century-old history structures. SouthEast Development Group estimates that preserving and stabilizing the deteriorating buildings alone could cost up to $50 million, which is nearly 40% of the total development cost. 

This financial burden has led some City Council members to question whether the investment is justified, especially given the buildings deteriorated state.

Deterioration

Councilman Ron Salem has voiced concerns about the prolonged vacancy and deterioration of the buildings, suggesting that new construction on the site could potentially offer greater benefits to downtown development. The idea is to open the site for new projects that could revitalize the area more effectively than the costly restoration of the existing structures.

Preservation vs. Progress

On the other hand, preservation advocates argue that the Laura St. Trio holds intrinsic historical and cultural value that cannot be quantified. Designed by renowned architect Henry Klutho, these buildings are among the few remaining examples of his work in Jacksonville. Councilman Jimmy Peluso has strongly opposed the demolition, emphasizing the importance of maintaining the city’s historical fabric.

The Price for Preservation

Steve Atkins, the principal of SouthEast Development Group, also supports preservation, highlighting the buildings’ significance to Jacksonville’s downtown identity. He believes that restoring these historic buildings could contribute to the city’s cultural and historical landscape, attracting more visitors and fostering a sense of community pride. However, the incentives being pursued to restore the buildings are either beyond what the city thinks is fair and reasonable or is able to contribute.

Overall, the potential demolition of the historic Laura Street Trio in Jacksonville is being considered due to several factors:

1. Vacancy and Deterioration: The buildings have been vacant and deteriorating for about 30 years1. Despite multiple restoration attempts, the buildings remain in poor condition.
2. High Restoration Costs: The cost to stabilize and restore the buildings is estimated to be around $50 million. This high expense is a significant barrier to redevelopment.
3. Development Opportunities: Some City Council members believe that demolishing the buildings could open up opportunities for new construction that might better serve downtown development.

What’s Next?

As discussions continue, the fate of the Laura Street Trio remains in the balance. The special City Council committee will need to carefully consider the costs and benefits of both demolition and restoration. The decision will ultimately shape the future of downtown Jacksonville, determining whether the city prioritizes historical preservation or new development opportunities.

Thoughts?

What are your thoughts on this debate? Should Jacksonville preserve its historical landmarks or pave the way for new developments?

Here’s a recent video of the Laura Street Trio produced by our media partners, Fun To Watch.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Develop Jacksonville (@developjax)

Please leave this field empty

MAJOR DEVELOPMENT

Subscribe for trending topics and major developments!

Email Address *

We don’t spam! Only the good stuff.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.